GENEVA: The UN special rapporteur on torture has urged US
authorities to investigate and weigh criminal charges against jail
officials in Ohio, Tennessee, Oklahoma and Arkansas for the clearly
gratuitous infliction of severe pain and suffering from the use of
Tasers on inmates, citing a report published this week.
After
reviewing footage of jail incidents, Nils Melzer said the grave abuse
from Taser use in some US jails violated the United Nations prohibition
on cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment and, in some cases, amounted
to torture. He cited video footage of 22 incidents in four jails: in
Ohio, Tennessee, Arkansas and Oklahoma states.
In my
view, all of the incidents shown in this video require independent
investigation and most of them are likely to merit prosecution, Melzer
said in an interview. Clearly gratuitous infliction of severe pain and
suffering constitutes a grave violation of human dignity and of the
universal code of conduct for law enforcement officials.
His
criticisms were echoed by the head of the United Nations watchdog panel
that monitors US compliance with an anti-torture treaty, who said the
cases documented by Reuters need to be investigated thoroughly.
In
an article and accompanying video report published Wednesday, Reuters
identified 104 cases of prisoners who died after being shocked with
Tasers. Some of the in-custody deaths were deemed multi-factorial, with
no single cause, and some were attributed to pre-existing health
problems. But the Taser was listed as a cause or contributing factor in
more than a quarter of the 84 inmate fatalities in which the news agency
obtained cause-of-death findings.
Of the 104 inmates who
died, just two were armed when shocked and nearly 80 percent hadn’t
been convicted of a crime. A third were in handcuffs or other restraints
when stunned. In more than two-thirds of the 70 cases, the inmate
already was immobilised when pinned to the ground or held by officers.
When
you use a tool like this on an incapacitated person, to me it certainly
amounts to cruel and degrading treatment, Melzer said.
A
weapons manufacturer, Axon Enterprise, said stun guns can help jailers
and inmates avoid injuries when used properly. Axon issues guidance on
proper use and warns of the risks associated with its weapons, but the
company said it is up to local jail administrators to set their own
policies on how and when the weapons are deployed.
We do
not condone torture of any kind, Axon spokesman Steve Tuttle said in
response to Melzer’s call for an investigation. Our technology is
designed to protect life and reduce harm to all parties involved during
high risk, violent, and response-to-resistance situations.
Melzer
agreed Tasers can be a justifiable tool for prison guards as an
alternative to a gun to incapacitate a person who poses a threat.
Melzer
cited two of the 22 cases identified by Reuters to explain his belief
that an investigation is warranted. One was the 2009 stunning of Martini
Smith at a jail in Franklin County, Ohio. Previously unpublished video
footage showed the Tasers electrified darts striking the womans chest.
Smith,
who was pregnant and lost her baby after being stunned, was one of nine
inmates who filed a lawsuit against the county. Guards used Tasers at
least 180 times from Jan 2008 to May 2010, often on prisoners posing no
threat, the lawsuit contended.
In its own reviews, the sheriffs office found no wrongdoing by guards and said the Taser use did not constitute excessive force.
That
looks like a case of torture, Melzer said. She was threatened she would
be Tased if she didn’t comply with an order. It’s not that she
physically resisted or would have been dangerous to the officer.
The
Smith footage was among dozens of videos examined of Taser incidents at
the Ohio jail. Nineteen were featured in the video story. Melzer said
they revealed grave abuse. No deputies at Franklin County have been
charged.
The prosecutor’s office of a country said the US
Department of Justice did not recommend criminal charges against jail
officials when the justice department intervened on behalf of inmates in
the civil lawsuit stemming from the Taser incidents.
The
department “at no time treated these incidents as criminal conduct”,
the office said in a statement, noting that plaintiffs’ lawyers and
expert witnesses in the case also did not recommend criminal charges.
Melzer
also cited footage obtained of deputies in a jail in Cheatham county,
Tennessee, who repeatedly stunned 19-year-old Jordan Norris on Nov 5
last year, while he was strapped to a restraint chair. That footage also
was evidence of torture, Melzer said.
One deputy, Mark
Bryant, was charged in September with four counts of aggravated assault
and one count of official misconduct. Bryant has pleaded not guilty.
Neither he nor his lawyers could be reached for comment.
Jens
Modvig, chairman of the UN Committee against Torture, a panel of 10
independent experts, also said the documented incidents represented
blatant abuse that may violate laws. The United States, as a signatory
to the UN Convention against Torture, is obligated to investigate the
cases, he said. Once you introduce them, Modvig said of stun guns, it is
difficult to avoid cases of misuse.
